8:
だれの + Noun: Whose N?
だれ is a question word Who, and だれの+X means Whose X?. When someone asks それは だれのかばんですか, それ is marked with the topic particle はわ. By making it the topic, the speaker is treating “that" as already known in the situation. The question だれのかばんですか then asks the listener to identify to whom the bag belongs.
A: それは だれのかばんですか。(“Whose bag is it?”)
B: わたしのかばんです。 (“It’s my bag.”)
Similarly, if A asks にほんごのほんは どれですか, the phrase にほんごのほん is marked with the topic particle はわ. By making it the topic, A is treating “the Japanese-language book” as already known or assumed to exist in the situation. The question どれですか then asks B to identify which object it is among the visible options. Because the identity of the object (which one) is the new information, the natural answer focuses only on that point:
A: にほんごのほんは どれですか。
B: あれです。 (“It’s that one.”)
If B responds あれは にほんごのほんです here, it reverses the information structure. In that sentence, あれ is made the topic, and にほんごのほん is presented as new information—essentially answering a different question, such as: あれは なんですか (“What is that?”). In other words, にほんごのほんは どれですか asks the listener to identify an object, not to classify or explain what the object is. For this reason, あれは にほんごのほんです does not appropriately answer the original question.
9: な-Adjective (Non-past, Affirmative)
な-adjectives can also modify a noun (e.g., "a pretty room") like い-adjectives. な-adjectives require な before the noun as shown below.
| な-Adj な |
Noun |
|
| きれいな |
へや |
pretty/beautiful room |
| きれいな |
みず |
clean water |
| りっぱな |
せんせい |
fine teacher |
| すてきな |
いえ |
nice house |
| ゆうめいな |
ひと |
famous person |
| らくな |
いす |
comfortable chair |
| げんきな |
こども |
healthy/energetic child |
The following are opposite pairs. Some (marked by a ✅) are い-adjectives introduced in the grammar notes above.
| しずか |
quiet |
にぎやか |
cheerfully noisy |
| べんり |
convenient |
ふべん |
inconvenient |
| ✅いい |
good |
だめ |
no good |
| ✅いそがしい |
busy |
ひま |
not busy |
な-Adjectives can be embedded in noun sentences as shown below.
| あれは |
ゆうめいな |
え |
ですか。 |
Is that a famous painting? |
| ええ、 |
ゆうめいな |
え |
です。 |
Yes, that's a famous painting. |
| ええ、 |
|
そう |
です。 |
Yes, that's right. |
| いいえ、 |
ゆうめいな |
え |
じゃありません。
じゃないです。 |
No, that's not a famous painting. |
| いいえ、 |
|
そう |
じゃありません。
じゃないです。 |
No, that's not correct. |
10: Adjectival Sentence 1: な-Adjective +です
Adjectives can also be used in adjectival sentences (e.g., Sentences that end with な-Adj+です) as shown below. The negative forms of な-adjective sentences are the same as those used in noun sentences. な-adjective sentences behave more like a noun sentences in this sense.
| あれは |
ゆうめい |
ですか。 |
Is that famous? |
| ええ、 |
ゆうめい |
です。 |
Yes, that's famous. |
| いいえ、 |
ゆうめい |
じゃありません。
じゃないです。 |
No, it's not famous. |
If な-adjectives conjugate like nouns, why don’t we simply call them な-nouns? One way to identify a true noun in Japanese is that it can be replaced by the demonstrative そう (“so / that”), which refers back to previously mentioned information. For example: それは ペンですか。→ ええ、そうです。 Here, そう stands in for the noun ペン, confirming that ペン functions as a noun. However, this substitution is not possible with な-adjectives as noted by an * below:
| カフェテリアは しずかですか。 |
Is the cafeteria quiet? |
* ええ、そうです。
|
[Ungrammatical]
|
| * いいえ、そうじゃありません。 |
[Ungrammatical] |
| The correct response for B is: ええ、しずかです or いいえ、しずかじゃありません. |
The following are additional examples why な-adjectives are not a noun. The adverb like とても (very; See below) can be used with な-adjectives. This cannot be done with nouns.
それは とても べんりです。 That is very convenient.
* それは とても ほんです。 [Ungrammatical]
The particle の is used for combining a noun with another noun while な is used for combining な-adjective with a noun.
にほんの ひと: a person in Japan
きれいな ひと: a pretty person
These facts show that な-adjectives behave differently from nouns at a deeper grammatical level. For this reason, despite surface similarities in conjugation, な-adjectives are classified as adjectives, not nouns.
11:
とても + Aff. and あまり + Neg. with な-Adjectives
な-adjectives can be modified by とても (very) and あまり ([not] very). とても is followed by an affirmative expression and あまり is followed by a negative expression. Note that あまり itself does not contain the negative meaning and it must be followed by a negative expression to become a complete expression. (あまり can also be あんまり which is a casual form of あまり.)
|
|
|
| とても |
きれい |
です。 |
It's very beautiful/pretty/clean. |
| とても |
きれいな |
へやです。 |
It's a very beautiful room. |
|
|
|
| あまり |
きれい |
じゃありません。
じゃないです。 |
It's not very beautiful/pretty/clean. |
| あまり |
きれいな |
へやじゃありません。
へやじゃないです。 |
It's not a very beautiful room. |
|